3 Statistics Lessons from a Summer as a Science Journalist
December 6, 2018
Irineo Cabreros is an AAAS Mass Media Fellow with the sponsorship of the American Statistical Association. He spent 10 weeks this summer training as a science journalist with Slate in its New York City offices.
This summer I had the opportunity to write for the science desk at Slate magazine as an AAAS Mass Media Fellow sponsored by the ASA. While at Slate, I was surrounded by a community of passionate, amazing journalists.
Slate is a special place with a special spirit about it. They pride themselves in an ability to offer fresh, unorthodox angles on any story, big or small. It’s a place for skeptics, contrarians and obsessives. In many ways, Slate people are my kind of people.
I had a lot to learn when I arrived at Slate. I was pushed out of my comfort zone and challenged tremendously. But as a result, I grew a lot.
Here are the top 3 lessons I learned while working as a science journalist at Slate this summer:
1 . Relevance is King
During my time at Slate, I was forced to ask myself questions about science that I rarely thought about as a while doing science:
Will a typical person understand what I’m saying? This sentence isn’t quite air-tight, but is a gain in precision worth the potential losses in confusion? And really, will anyone really care about this? Should they? If so, how can I convince them it matters?
In journalism, relevance to a reader’s life always must always take center stage.
The practice of asking these questions also spilled over to my work as a scientist. In thinking daily about the effect of statistics to an average person while at Slate, I was forced to think about the impact that my own work might have on people outside of academia. It’s easy to get tunnel vision in graduate school; this summer forced me to zoom out.
2. Statistics is Slippery, Subtle and Everywhere in Science
Statistics is used in virtually every scientific field, and a little knowledge of statistics can go a long way in science journalism. Many scientific studies that garner general public interest—whether it be a medical study, a climate model, sport science, nutrition science, or psychology—rely heavily on statistical arguments. It takes some statistical savvy to wade through it all at journalistic pace, separating genuinely compelling findings from the more preliminary stuff.
The fact that many journalists don’t come from a statistical background contributes to the seemingly contradictory “scientific discoveries” that find their way into the media. Red wine is good for you one day, then bad for you the next, then good for you again. Premature reporting of half-baked results may ultimately erode the public’s trust in science.
Several of my favorite pieces from this summer drew on my expertise in statistics to comment on scientific studies. I wrote a critique of a much-hyped study that some believed implied the possibility of immortality. But as basic probability makes clear, I argued the unfortunate but sober truth that you are definitely going to die. In the heat of the summer, with temperature records dropping all over the globe, I reported on the statistics of attribution: Can we really blame the summer heat on global warming?
3. Statistics is Everywhere Else, Too
Working as a journalist also gave me the incredible luxury of diving deep into some of my everyday curiosities.
As a Muslim, I had always wondered about the health effects of Ramadan fasting, and got to talk to some leaders in the field of longevity research who patiently answered all my questions. I also got to talk to butchers and bankers about logistics and impact of Islamic philanthropy. As an alum, I was naturally interested in Harvard’s high-profile discrimination lawsuit and got to dive deep into the statistical evidence presented in legal testimony. As a soccer enthusiast, I got to think about penalty kick strategy. As a health nut, I got to dive into the murky and world of omega-3 supplements.
It was both fun and informative to have a professional excuse to delve into my personal interests—statistics is omnipresent.
A New Direction
My experiences this summer got me hooked: I left Slate flush with inspiration for future projects and hungry to keep going. I began the summer as a dabbler in science communication.
Now, I don’t think I can imagine a future without journalism being a part of it.
Further reading about statistics in journalism:
- Jeremy Singer-Vine Has the Buzz on Using Data in Journalism
- From Spreadsheets to Headlines: A Day in the Life of Data Journalist Ryan Struyk
- Real or Fake News? Let Statistics Help
Statisticians and data scientists truly have the power to change the world for the better. Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, statisticians, like Dr. Kathy Ensor, conducted crucial data analysis to inform real-world public health decisions. And that’s just the beginning! In addition to her work teaching the next generation of statisticians at George R. Brown School…
In this year’s Fall Data Challenge, After the Bell, 72 teams and 262 students submitted their data analyses on how to enhance familial involvement in the K-12 educational experience using data from the National Household Education Surveys Program (NHES)’s 2019 Parents and Family Involvement (PFI) Survey. “Our annual Fall Data Challenge continues to be an opportunity…